Best 4-Star Hotels in Eleuthera Island
Luxury travel isn’t defined by stars alone, but by a combination of factors that enhance the overall experience. Each property featured within our selection of the best 4-star hotels has been chosen for its exceptional service and meticulous attention to detail at every stage of the guest journey. Interiors and exteriors are finished to a high standard, combining thoughtful design with a sense of place. Facilities and amenities are of a quality that exceeds guest expectations, while each hotel’s location enhances and enriches the overall stay, whether through cultural connection, natural beauty, or urban vibrancy.
This collection reflects the very best of the 4-star category, ideal for those seeking sophistication, character, and comfort in equal measure.
Eleuthera Island, Governorʼs Harbour
French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection
(4 stars)Found on the west side of the island in Colebrooke Dale, adjacent to Governor’s Harbour, this all-villa whitewashed resort overlooks the historic Cupid’s Cay. Take a wicker seat on a terrace by the ocean for locally inspired meals served at the highly-rated 1648 – An Island Restaurant, where the daily catch and fresh fish feature prominently on the menu. An infinity edge pool also overlooks the water, as does the low rise guest accommodation, and the beach provides plenty of snorkelling and swimming opportunities. i-Pad concierge services, L’Occitane or Molton Brown toiletries and premium movie channels come as standard at the French Leave Resort.